51 products analyzed by our AI • Prices updated on 09/27/2026
Ranking established by our AI from spec sheets, retailer prices and verified reviews (methodology). Comparr may earn a commission through merchant links, with no impact on the ranking.
AI ranking · commissioned links, no effect on the ranking (methodology).
AI-optimized search: "melatonin supplements"
The best melatonin supplements in 2026 are the Neuro Mints Sleep & Recharge Melatonin (best choice, ~$29.99), the Natrol Advanced Sleep Melatonin Tablets (best value, ~$9.99), and the up & up Melatonin 5mg Supplement Tablets (budget choice, ~$3.29). When choosing a supplement, key criteria include dosage, form (tablets, gummies, fast-dissolve), and price per count. Our top picks cater to different needs: premium options for those prioritizing innovative delivery and high ratings, value picks for balanced performance, and budget-friendly choices for effective, affordable solutions.
According to our AI analysis, the best melatonin supplements in 2026 are the Neuro Mints Sleep & Recharge Melatonin (the top pick, $29.99), the Melatonin Fast Dissolve Natrol (the best value for money, $9.99) and the up & up Melatonin 5mg Supplement Tablets (the best budget option, $3.29).
Every price in this comparison on a single ruler — hover to see each product.
51 products priced from $3.29 to $29.99, median price $11.97.
Sweep the ruler, tap a winner, or use the arrow keys.
Swipe the ruler: the needle stops on a product every time.
Neuro Mints Sleep & Recharge Melatonin, though pricier at $29.99, stands out with a 4.8 rating and an innovative mint form for quick absorption and convenience.
Nature Made 5 mg Melatonin Extra Strength Gummies, with a 4.8 rating at $14.39, offer a delicious and effective solution for consistent sleep support.
SuperSmart Melatonin 3mg, with a perfect 5.0 rating at $11.00, offers a highly effective and precisely dosed option for those seeking optimal quality.
Natrol Advanced Sleep Melatonin Tablets with a 4.7 rating and fast-dissolve formula for $9.99 provide excellent user convenience and effectiveness for its price.
Natrol Melatonin Gummies at $10.98 deliver 10mg dosage in a convenient gummy form, combining good taste with effective sleep support.
Now Melatonin 5 mg is priced at $7.58 with a high rating of 4.8, offering reliable quality and dosage for everyday use.
At just $3.29, the up & up Melatonin 5mg Supplement Tablets offer exceptional value for daily use, providing a standard dosage at an unbeatable price point.
Spring Valley Melatonin 10mg tablets at $5.94 offer a higher dosage and a substantial count, making them a very cost-effective choice for regular users.
Nature's Bounty Dual Spectrum Melatonin Bi-Layer Tablets for $5.99 provide a unique bi-layer technology for sustained release at an attractive price.
Les meilleurs parmi les résultats trouvés
This Spring Valley Melatonin offers a good balance of quantity (120 count) and a higher dosage (10mg) at a very competitive price point, making it excellent value for money.
Natrol's Fast Dissolve Melatonin is a highly relevant pick due to its convenient form factor, which allows for quicker absorption compared to standard tablets, making it ideal for those seeking faster effects.
For users who prefer an alternative to tablets, Natrol Melatonin Gummies provide a palatable and easy-to-take option with a potent 10mg dosage, offering a different but equally effective delivery method.
Données issues des fiches techniques des marchands. « Non communiqué » signale une information non disponible — nous ne l'estimons pas.
| Critère |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prix | $5.94 | $5.99 | $8.99 | $8.96 | $9.99 | $15.49 |
| Brand | Spring Valley | Nature's Bounty | Nature Made | Natrol | Natrol | CVS Health |
| Count | 120 count | 60 count | 90 count | 60 count | 100 count | Unknown |
| Dosage | 10mg | 5mg | 5mg | 10mg | 5mg | Unknown |
| Form | Tablets | Bi-Layer Tablets | Tablets | Tablets | Fast Dissolve Tablets | Gummies |
| Product type | Melatonin Supplement | Melatonin Supplement | Melatonin Supplement | Melatonin Supplement | Melatonin Supplement | Sleep Aid Gummies |
| Key ingredient | Melatonin | Melatonin | Melatonin | Melatonin | Melatonin | Melatonin |
| Spec |
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Prix | $5.94 | $5.99 | $9.99 |
| Fast Dissolve Form | |||
| Gummy Form | |||
| 10mg Dosage | |||
| Bi-Layer Tablets | |||
| Time Release Form | |||
| Added Ingredients (e.g., Magnesium) |
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Prix | $5.94 | $5.99 | $9.99 |
| Fast Dissolve Form | |||
| Gummy Form | |||
| 10mg Dosage | |||
| Bi-Layer Tablets | |||
| Time Release Form | |||
| Added Ingredients (e.g., Magnesium) |
Touchez une colonne pour la surligner.
| Produit | Source | Prix | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $5.94 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $5.99 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $8.99 | Voir | |
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $8.96 | Voir | |
| Walgreens.Com checked Sep 27 | $9.99 | Voir | |
| Cvs Pharmacy checked Sep 27 | $15.49 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $12.89 | Voir | |
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $10.98 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $13.79 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $8.99 | Voir |
| Produit | Source | Prix | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walgreens.Com checked Sep 27 | $11.99 | Voir | |
| Walgreens.Com checked Sep 27 | $5.99 | Voir | |
| Vitafusion checked Sep 27 | $12.49 | Voir | |
| Cvs Pharmacy checked Sep 27 | $16.49 | Voir | |
| Cvs Pharmacy checked Sep 27 | $8.99 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $12.49 | Voir | |
| Walgreens.Com checked Sep 27 | $12.99 | Voir | |
| Best Naturals checked Sep 27 | $9.99 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $3.29 | Voir | |
| Neurogum.Com checked Sep 27 | $29.99 | Voir | |
| Cvs Pharmacy checked Sep 27 | $12.99 | Voir | |
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $11.97 | Voir | |
| Carewell checked Sep 27 | $15.98 | Voir | |
| Thorne checked Sep 27 | $16.00 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $14.39 | Voir | |
| Ez Melts checked Sep 27 | $16.99 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $5.99 | Voir | |
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $9.97 | Voir | |
| Pureformulas.Com checked Sep 27 | $7.58 | Voir | |
| Allmax Nutrition checked Sep 27 | $9.99 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $7.89 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $27.99 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $8.99 | Voir | |
| Sam's Club checked Sep 27 | $10.97 | Voir | |
| The Vitamin Shoppe checked Sep 27 | $12.99 | Voir | |
| Thrive Market checked Sep 27 | $25.09 | Voir | |
| Macy's checked Sep 27 | $13.99 | Voir | |
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $13.88 | Voir | |
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $13.96 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $4.79 | Voir | |
| Life Extension checked Sep 27 | $9.00 | Voir | |
| Cvs Pharmacy checked Sep 27 | $22.99 | Voir | |
| Walgreens.Com checked Sep 27 | $12.99 | Voir | |
| Vitacost.Com checked Sep 27 | $13.57 | Voir | |
| Puritan's Pride checked Sep 27 | $6.79 | Voir | |
| Iherb checked Sep 27 | $5.50 | Voir | |
| Walmart checked Sep 27 | $10.00 | Voir | |
| Target checked Sep 27 | $11.99 | Voir | |
| Nordstrom checked Sep 27 | $11.00 | Voir | |
| Cvs Pharmacy checked Sep 27 | $16.79 | Voir | |
| Macy's checked Sep 27 | $11.09 | Voir |
When choosing melatonin supplements, consider the dosage (5mg is common, 10mg for stronger needs), the form (tablets, gummies, or fast-dissolve for quicker action), and any additional ingredients. Budget-friendly options like up & up and Spring Valley are ideal for basic, consistent use, while value selections such as Natrol Fast Dissolve and Gummies offer enhanced user experience. For those prioritizing innovation and premium quality, products like Neuro Mints or SuperSmart provide advanced delivery and high ratings. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any new supplement.
For fast relief, consider fast-dissolve tablets like Natrol Advanced Sleep Melatonin Tablets ($8.96) or CVS Melatonin Sleep Aid 12 MG Fast Dissolve Tablets ($16.49). These forms are designed to be absorbed quickly into the bloodstream.
Yes, melatonin gummies are effective and often preferred for their taste and ease of use. Top-rated options include Nature Made 5 mg Melatonin Extra Strength Gummies ($14.39) and Natrol Melatonin Gummies ($10.98), both offering good dosages and positive user feedback.
For beginners, a 3mg to 5mg dosage is often recommended. Products like Nature's Bounty Dual Spectrum Melatonin Bi-Layer Tablets (5mg, $5.99) or Now Melatonin 5 mg ($7.58) are excellent starting points to assess your body's response.
For excellent value, the up & up Melatonin 5mg Supplement Tablets at $3.29 provide a solid dosage at an incredibly low price. Spring Valley Melatonin 10mg Tablets for $5.94 also offer a high count and dosage for consistent use.
Yes, some melatonin supplements combine melatonin with other sleep-supporting ingredients. For instance, New Chapter Magnesium + Plant Based Melatonin ($25.09) offers magnesium alongside melatonin for enhanced sleep support.
Bi-layer or time-release tablets, such as Nature's Bounty Dual Spectrum Melatonin Bi-Layer Tablets ($5.99) or Natrol Melatonin Time Release ($12.99), are designed to release melatonin in stages. This can help you fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer by providing a sustained release throughout the night.
The most viewed comparisons in the same category
Pick two products, the AI settles it
Proposez un produit, l'IA le situe.
Feature idea? Something broken? Your feedback shapes the Comparr of tomorrow. 🚀